2 phase versus 3 phase control for 3 phase loads

Engineers that wish to control 3 phase heaters often face a dilemma when selecting the power controllers. How do you decide which method of control to select?

  • 2 phase versus 3 phase control?
  • zero cross versus phase-angle control?

The answer lies in the 3-phase heater

The following will help you decide which method is appropriate for your kind of application.

3 phase control for a 3 phase load

3 phase, 3 leg power control WYE vs 3 phase 3 leg inside delta control

Switching all three legs of a 3-phase heater load is only necessary in the following situations:

  • Grounded ‘Y’ heater: each phase controls to neutral. Grounded heaters have 4 wires attached. The center of the ‘Y’ heater is connected to the neutral of the power distribution system.
  • Open delta: a pair of SCR’s (2 thyristors in parallel) control each heater in the delta. Open delta heaters have six wires attached or are three single-phase heaters wired in a open delta arrangement.
  • Three phase, phase angle-controlled loads: phase angle control requires that all three legs be switched. Phase-control should be selected for non-linear load devices such:
    • tungsten heaters
    • MoSi2 (i.e. Kanthal Super) heaters
    • primary side of transformers
    • other inductive loads
  • If any current limiting feature is required, phase angle control must be selected.
  • Heater Bake Out feature: Requires phase control to limit current through a heater. Heater bakeout is a function of certain thyristor modules where the current is limited through a heater to drive the moisture from the insulation of the heater. Once the moisture is removed, the heater may be operated in phase-angle or zero cross control.

2 phase control for a 3 phase load

3 phase 2 leg WYE and 2 leg delta power control

When zero cross control is selected for an ungrounded heater, it is better to switch only two legs.

Several reasons are:

  • Less electrical noise: the load turns on when the AC is at zero cross without clipping of the first AC waveform. Since no two phases of three phase systems ever cross zero volts at the same time, the load cannot turn on at the zero voltage crossing without a return path which results in a clipping of the sine wave at turn-on resulting in generated harmonics. Consequently, a two-leg power control unit produces less electrical noise.
  • Less dissipation heat: a three phase two-leg unit, will produce 1/3 less heat in the enclosure than a threeleg power control. An SCR dissipates approximately 1.2 watts per ampere passing through the device. A three-leg device controlling 30 amperes dissipates 108 watts versus a two-leg device controlling the same load dissipates 72 watts.
  • Lower cost: a three phase two-leg unit costs less to buy than a three-leg unit. In addition, semiconductor fuses are used only in controlled legs. Two semiconductor fuses with holders cost 1/3 less than three semiconductor fuses with holders.
  • Safety: a three leg (6 SCRs, so 3 pairs of 2 thyristors in parallel) power control is an illusion of safety. Thyristors always have a very small (microamperes) leakage current in closed state, so the full voltage, albeit with almost no current (so no actual power in watts) will always be present at the load. Only a three pole electromechanical contactor relay meets the definition of a disconnect. A disconnection with an electromechanical relay provides for a positive mechanical break on all hot legs simultaneously. An SCR is not a mechanical break device. The National Electrical Code requires a disconnect ahead of any SCR power control.